Posted: September 25th, 2022

Criminal Justice Ethics

Criminal Justice Ethics
Case Examine Paper:
The ultimate task for the course is a 5-page (double-spaced, 12-point Instances New Roman
font, 1-inch margins) paper analyzing one of many case research (not movies) lined within the
course.
It’s price 50 factors.
The papers should analyze
one of many 4 instances mentioned through the semester and must be organized within the
following method and comprise the next subheadings:
• Assertion of the issue
o What’s the moral downside or dilemma posed by the case research?
o What’s at stake? What are the implications related to the choice that
have to be made?
• Utility of Concept
o Analyze the issue utilizing not less than two (or extra) of the moral theories lined
within the course. Use APA type references as acceptable.
o What would the possible consequence of the case be below every of the theories?
• Conclusion
o How would you resolve this case?
o What are the potential counter-arguments to your place? How would you
reply to them?

The ebook to be cited can be

Criminal Justice Ethics
Cyndi Banks fifth version

Defunding the Police
Assertion of the Downside
A code of ethics has been established to information the regulation enforcement group together with loyalty, allegiance, braveness, and honesty. Merely put, the code of ethics guides the regulation enforcers in doing the correct factor and serving the individuals no matter their neighborhood (Louise & Steve, 2020). Nonetheless, in recent times the police have publicly been criticized by activist teams, the general public, and the media for consistently demonstrating violence, significantly within the minority communities such because the African American communities elevating concern concerning ethics within the regulation enforcement sector.
Moral Downside
On Could 25, 2020, The US and the world at giant had been despatched to a shock after a 46-year-old black man referred to as George Floyd was publicly murdered within the streets of Minneapolis by a white police officer referred to as Derek Chauvin. George Floyd had been arrested on suspicion of getting a $20 that was alleged to be counterfeit. The arrest captured by witnesses demonstrated George Floyd being pinned to the bottom by the officer who didn’t hearken to George’s pleas that he couldn’t breathe (Louise & Steve, 2020). The occasion led to the suffocation and eventual dying of George Floyd over an occasion that would have been simply solved if he was arrested in the correct method. This occasion raised a variety of issues and questions concerning the moral code of conduct amongst cops particularly in terms of serving the minority communities within the nation. Luckily, video footage by bystanders dropped at mild the continuing atrocities carried out by brogue cops, atrocities beforehand ignored as a result of lack of proof. Many urged that the consequence of the motion and different associated actions must be defunding and lowering the sources allotted to police departments to take care of their repeated cases of misconduct.
What’s at stake and what penalties?
Defunding the police entails chopping down their price range and lowering the sources allotted to their departments. Whereas many assume that this may be step one to minimizing the numerous cases of misconduct, it could additionally create a harmful state of affairs for a lot of communities particularly these liable to violence and crime. Regardless of the numerous instances of violence and misconduct, police have been instrumental; in bringing peace to a few of the violent and crime-prone communities. Defunding the police would lead to elevated chaos in these communities (Louise & Steve, 2020). Much less price range would additionally imply that there aren’t any enough sources to supply officers with cultural-awareness coaching and the way to use their forces. Furthermore, you will need to take into account that not all cops are rogue, subsequently, it’s fallacious to punish the great officers due to the misconducts of their rogue counterparts.
Utility of Concept
Utilitarianism Concept
This moral idea determines what is taken into account proper or fallacious from, the outcomes. If the outcomes of an motion are proper then the motion is taken into account to be acceptable, nonetheless, if the outcomes are unfavorable, the motion is taken into account fallacious. On this case, the position of the police contains serving the individuals by offering them with security and safety (Banks, 2018). The anticipated outcomes are that their actions will result in the well-being of the society by enhancing peace and safety. Their actions whereas at work ought to lead to the perfect constructive outcomes potential. Nonetheless, as demonstrated by their repeated misconduct cases, it’s clear that their motion is ethically fallacious as they’re consistently resulting in continued endangerment of the general public, significantly for these from minority communities (Ugonna & Mgbechi, 2019). As an illustration, the motion of officer Derek Chauvin led to the dying of a black man who was not even resisting arrest. For his actions to be thought of to be ethically proper, Derek ought to have arrested George Floyd the correct means and brought him to jail if he was certainly in possession of the counterfeit invoice to await his courtroom case.
The actions of Derek Chauvin’s actions will be thought of to be unethical and unprofessional warranting excessive ranges of punishment. As well as, they had been a mirrored image of the rogue habits demonstrated by many different officers within the drive (Louise & Steve, 2020). The results of his motion led to his arrest and he was charged with manslaughter. His actions additionally sparked a public uproar triggering elevated emphasis on the gross misconducts of rogue cops with many suggesting that the one approach to punish this unethical misconduct is thru defunding.
The Advantage Concept
Regulation enforcement companies emphasize that their officers be on their finest habits to mirror the values of their companies. Regarding suspects and offenders, the idea argues that the state on this case cops is obligated by obligation and ethics to acknowledge offenders and criminals to type their ethical character by way of rational choice-making even whereas below state supervision (Banks, 2018). On this case, George Floyd and different arrested suspects must be handled as equal residents and arrested by means of the correct procedures except when the suspect is resisting arrest or responding by means of violent measures. This case was a mirrored image of the poor morals and values massive proportion of the regulation enforcement sector is constructed upon.
When the company identifies the traits they require of their officers they’ve a excessive likelihood of attracting candidates with these traits. Failure of doing these ends in them hiring officers who lack integrity and fail to watch their code of ethics. As an illustration, the US police company has been characterised by quite a few instances of misconduct, violence, and aggressiveness in the direction of the blacks and different minority communities (Banks, 2018). From a public and media perspective, regulation enforcement companies are characterised by corruption, violence, and misconduct (Louise & Steve, 2020). Subsequently, the company fails to mirror correct values to the neighborhood owing to the unhealthy repute that it has constructed upon over time. Subsequently, it turns into troublesome for the company to draw well-behaved officers who can positively mirror the values of the company. This explains why the police company is characterised by a nasty repute with officers similar to Derek Chauvin amongst many others demonstrating the rotten part of the regulation enforcement companies. With such a nasty repute it’s troublesome for the well-behaved officers to be acknowledged and appreciated as their actions are overshadowed by these of the rogue officers.
Conclusion
For a few years, regulation enforcement companies have been related to violence and aggressiveness, significantly in the direction of minor communities. Sadly, most instances haven’t been dropped at mild as a result of an absence of ample proof. The publicized case of George Floyd amongst many others is a transparent illustration of the shortage of ethics within the police sector. The utilitarian and advantage idea intimately explains the fallacious actions of the police and the way they mirror the state of the regulation enforcement company within the US. The utilitarian idea argues that the outcomes of an motion present whether or not the motion is correct or fallacious. Within the case of George Floyd, the actions of the officer led to the dying of Floyd making his actions fallacious. From a advantage idea perspective, the rogue actions of Derek Chauvin are a mirrored image of the unethical and unprofessional habits upheld by most officers. Nonetheless, you will need to take into account that different well-behaved cops observe their code of ethics and act accordingly.
How I might resolve this case and Counterargument
The repeated misconducts of the police display that certainly there are a variety of rogue characters within the drive who have to be punished. Defunding the regulation enforcement companies is nonetheless not the police. Most cops have been instrumental in enhancing the scrutiny of the American communities. The present peace and safety encountered in many of the neighborhoods will be attributed to those officers who’ve dutifully performed their position. Subsequently, it could be fallacious to defund the entire police division as a result of misconduct and errors of some within the division. The bests technique is to establish rogue cops and topic them to heavy punishments in order that they will function examples to their friends (Banks, 2018). The opposite technique is to spend money on coaching concerning cultural consciousness and using drive to make sure that the officers perceive their roles and extremes that they don’t seem to be round to go to. This fashion they’ll have elevated capabilities and information to even take care of resistant suspects and offenders with out inflicting hurt. Coaching must be offered throughout recruitment and likewise commonly because the cops proceed with their service.

References
Banks, C. (2018). Criminal Justice Ethics: Concept and Apply. SAGE.
Louise, W., & Steve, C. (2020). Police ethics and integrity: Preserving the ‘blue code of silence. Worldwide Journal of Police Science and Administration, 22(four), 378-392.
Ugonna, A., & Mgbechi. (2019). Multidimensional Moral Dilemmas of Modern Organizations: A Literature Assessment. Worldwide Journal of Innovation and Financial Growth, 5(three), 7-18.

Order | Check Discount

Tags: Criminal Justice Ethics