Who was the biggest contributor to the demise of Romeo and Juliet? On this essay I might be writing about William Shakespeare’s play Romeo and Juliet, I might be doing an in-depth Assessment as to who I feel is most to blame for the unhappy eventual deaths of Romeo and Juliet, analysing every character intimately. First, let’s begin with the normal storyline. It’s fourteenth century Verona, an Italian metropolis. Two households, the Capulet’s and Montague’s, have been feuding for centuries, the cause for this we by no means truly discover out.
The 2 lovers, Romeo and Juliet, after an unlucky sequence of occasions which I’ll clarify later, each find yourself dying, however who’s to blame for them dying? That’s what I’m explaining on this essay. Mercutio is a kinsman to the prince and good friend of Romeo. He’s neither Montague or Capulet however he stays on the facet of the Montague as a result of he’s Romeo’s good friend.
Some of his most well-known quotes in the play embody; “Ask for me tomorrow, and you shall discover me a grave man”, and “A plague a’each your homes!
They’ve made worms’ meat of me. ” Mercutio persuades Romeo at the begin of the play to go to the Capulet occasion, which is the place Romeo met Juliet in the first place. I don’t suppose he can blamed for their deaths on this method as he didn’t even know Juliet existed at that time. Afterward in the play, Mercutio and Romeo are hanging out collectively when Tybalt comes up to them, Tybalt then insults Romeo in an try to provoke a battle however Romeo responds calmly and it’s Mercutio who then fights with Tybalt, in defence of his good friend.
Romeo tries to cease the battle however in the confusion, Tybalt stabs Mercutio and dies shortly afterwards. Mercutio didn’t want to begin a battle with Tybalt as he isn’t a Montague, he didn’t maintain a grudge in opposition to him. When Mercutio obtained killed, this fuelled Romeo for revenge as Tybalt had simply killed his greatest good friend and walked away from it along with his head held excessive. Romeo went after Tybalt and caught him unexpectedly, subsequently killing him as nicely.
When Prince Escalus heard about the two deaths, he couldn’t do something about Mercutio’s demise as the one who had carried it out was now lifeless, he had been killed by Romeo, who was nonetheless alive, he despatched Romeo into exile. He banished him to Mantua, which made it close to inconceivable for him to see Juliet once more. Mercutio was to blame for this as he had began off an pointless battle in the first place and with out that taking place Romeo wouldn’t have gone after Tybalt as he didn’t need to trigger hurt to him as a result of at this level, Romeo and Juliet have been married however no person knew.
He couldn’t inform Tybalt that they have been married, as a Montague-Capulet marriage was strictly forbidden and morally unacceptable for each the households, however as we noticed, Romeo and Juliet couldn’t cover their love for one another and had to be collectively. The banishment of Romeo made him much more saddened and depressed as he didn’t get to see Juliet. I might say that Mercutio is partly accountable for the eventual tragic deaths of Romeo and Juliet, however not the most accountable. The Nurse is a servant to the Capulet family, and has been Juliet’s carer since beginning.
In the days when the play was set, it was normal follow for wealthy households like the Capulet’s to make use of a nurse to take care of the little one full time, from beginning, and she remains to be taking care of Juliet now at Juliet’s age of 13. All through the play, I feel she is the solely actual individual that Juliet can flip to for steering, her father is intent on her marrying Depend Paris, her mom additionally, not likely listening to Juliet’s emotions, simply doing what they suppose is greatest for the future welfare of their household. Juliet feels nearer to the nurse, you’ll be able to inform this by the language she makes use of when talking to them in contrast to her mom.
She addresses her mom by “Madam”, and the conversations between her and her mom are correct, and formal, whereas when she is speaking to the nurse she is rather a lot simpler about telling the nurse about her opinions, and the nurse is the similar together with her, giving her recommendation when wanted and discussing her emotions together with her. She is the solely character affiliated with the Capulet’s that is aware of all through the play about the relationship Romeo and Juliet are having. Though she might be Juliet’s closest companion all through the play, giving her recommendation, a shoulder to cry on, she is at all times there.
The morning after Romeo kills Tybalt, Capulet has a violent row with Juliet attempting to persuade her to marry Paris which she clearly doesn’t need to as a result of she desires to be with Romeo, however both Capulet or Woman Capulet is aware of about her and Romeo. Juliet refuses level clean to marry Paris and this outrages her father, leaving him in a violent rage. She asks the nurse for consolation, however the nurse, understanding about her and Romeo, goes in opposition to what she desires and agrees that she ought to marry Paris as a substitute of run away with Romeo.
This leaves Juliet feeling upset and that there now I nobody for her to go to, as her solely particular person she might lookup to has now gone in opposition to her. The nurse leaves her at the most crucial time she wanted Help and this doesn’t do her any good because it makes her extra down about Romeo’s exile than ever earlier than. Her mom thinks that she is upset as a result of of her cousin Tybalt being killed by Romeo. If it was ever extra unsuitable for Romeo and Juliet to be collectively, it was now, as earlier than he was solely a Montague, however now he had killed one of their very own.
She has to be out of Juliet’s confidence by the time Juliet drinks the potion, since she might most likely by no means have carried off a convincing act the subsequent morning if she had identified Juliet wasn’t actually lifeless. The nurse additionally helps organize the marriage between Romeo and Juliet with Friar Laurence. She goes to discover Romeo, and says, “For the gentlewoman is younger and due to this fact, should you ought to deal double together with her, really it have been an ailing factor to be provided to any gentlewoman, and very weak dealing”, that means that she makes certain that Romeo is aware of that he higher imply that he desires to marry Juliet, warning him.
She modified her thoughts after Juliet had the row together with her Father as I mentioned earlier than, placing her underneath extra stress and Juliet having suicidal ideas. I might say that the Nurse has quite a bit of duty for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet, extra so Juliet. He’s a nephew to Lord Capulet and a cousin to Juliet. He doesn’t discuss many traces, however he influences the complete course of the play although he has a minor function. All through the play, he demonstrates his offended, resentful, and commanding nature.
On the first day, he spots Romeo at the Capulet occasion and is outraged by this, however his Uncle, Capulet, refuses to let him cope with Romeo, angering him much more, so he units out on a revenge mission, that’s how he finally dies in the finish, as a result of he picks a battle with Romeo when Romeo doesn’t need to, Mercutio steps in, he kills Mercutio, and Romeo then goes on and kills him as I defined earlier on in the essay. You possibly can sense in the play that Tybalt is powered by the hate his household have for the Montague’s. Tybalt would do something to begin a battle with them as a result of of the rivalry.
He’s prepared to put his life on the line for the honor of his household. When he’s killed by Romeo, he might be blamed for digging his personal grave, as he had already killed Mercutio which angered Romeo. This drove Romeo mad, which killed Tybalt. This deeply upset Juliet, and to rub salt in the wounds it was Romeo, the one she had fallen in love with, that had killed her cousin. Some of his well-known quotes embody “Peace? Peace. I hate the phrase, as I hate hell, all Montague’s, and thee,” and “A villain that hath are available in spite / to scorn at our solemnity this night time! General I feel he’s partly accountable for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet, primarily for triggering Romeo to kill him, which additionally upset Juliet. Capulet, or Lord Capulet, is Juliet’s father and Tybalt’s cousin. Some of his well-known quotes embody; “get thee to church o’ Thursday, Or by no means after look me in the face, converse not, reply not, don’t reply me; my fingers itch,” and “Dangle thee, Younger baggage! Disobedient wretch! I inform the what- get thee to church on Thursday Or by no means look me in the face”.
You possibly can inform immediately from these quotes that he’s very insistent that Juliet marry Depend Paris as he’s linked to the Prince, which might larger the Capulet’s society standing and get extra money. Additionally, Juliet is the Capulet’s solely little one, due to this fact the solely method to carry the household on, so that they want to select her husband correctly. Juliet doesn’t need to marry Paris, as I’ve talked about earlier in earlier scenes, she retains refusing to marry him till finally Capulet loses all his mood together with her and has a violent outburst, threatening to disown her if she doesn’t marry him.
She can not marry him as a result of at this level she is clearly already married to Romeo, and Friar Laurence couldn’t marry her once more. She doesn’t need to marry Paris as a result of she feels she is just too younger, and desires to be with Romeo. She doesn’t inform her dad and mom this. Lord Capulet places her underneath nice strain to marry rely Paris. This can be one of the greatest components in her finally taking the sleeping potion, which, after an unlucky collection of occasions, obtained her killed.
Juliet clearly felt she had no alternative at this level, the nurse had left her, and she couldn’t marry as a result of she was already married, she couldn’t run away with Romeo as a result of he had been exiled. She went to the Friar for Help, and he got here up with an ingenious plan, which I’ll clarify later. I feel Lord Capulet was one of the foremost folks to contribute to the demise of Romeo and Juliet. Woman Capulet is Juliet’s mom and it’s clear from the begin that she and Juliet have a troubled relationship. That is most likely down to the nurse bringing her up her complete life and the nurse being extra of a mom to her.
Woman Capulet can also be eager on Juliet marrying Paris. The interactions between Woman Capulet and Juliet are strained and distant, not like the interactions between Juliet and the nurse. Why isn’t she shut to her daughter? Why isn’t she supportive when Juliet wants her most? Simply when Juliet wants her mom’s Help, Woman Capulet coldly ignores her daughter’s pleas to Help her keep away from marrying Paris. After Capulet storms out, Juliet turns to her mom to soften her father’s punishment. Juliet begs her even to delay the marriage.
Woman Capulet responds, “Speak not to me, for I’ll not say a phrase / Do as thou wilt, for I’ve executed with thee”. There might be a couple of various things happening right here. It appears very doubtless that Woman Capulet herself had an organized marriage with Juliet’s father, and it appears she went together with it obediently. When Juliet rebels in opposition to the deliberate marriage with Paris, she is rebelling in opposition to her mom’s method of life, and in opposition to the variety of marriage that Woman Capulet realized to endure by. She would possibly see this as an offence and that Juliet isn’t abiding with the method of life due to this fact ought to be punished.
Friar Laurence is the one who arranges Romeo and Juliet’s secret marriage, with Help from the nurse, and later offering Juliet with a drug which give her the look of demise, and thus keep away from having to marry Paris. Some of his well-known quotes embody “The grey-eyed morn smiles on the frowning night time, Chequering the jap clouds with streaks of gentle,” and “These violent delights have violent ends.
And of their triumph die, like hearth and powder. Friar Lawrence doesn’t instantly approve of Romeo’s plan to marry Juliet, and asks him “Is Rosaline, that thou didst love so expensive, So quickly forsaken? The Friar thought that if the households have been publicly identified about the marriage of Romeo and Juliet, it would settle the two household’s variations and they might get rather a lot with none brawls and the feud would cease. He says this by utilizing the line: “For this alliance might so glad show, to flip your home holds into pure love”. He shouldn’t had actually have married Romeo and Juliet in the first place, in any case, he knew he was doing unsuitable as a result of he was doing it in secret. He might be blamed for the deaths or Romeo and Juliet just because he let the marriage occur in the first place.
He additionally offered the sleeping capsule for Juliet to “play lifeless” in his ingenious plan for Juliet’s household to suppose she is lifeless, have her funeral and bury her in the Capulet’s resting chamber, the place she would get up and Romeo can be notified by submit. Nonetheless, the letter by no means obtained to him, as the messenger couldn’t ship it as a result of of the plague in the metropolis at the time. This led Romeo to suppose like everyone else was that his expensive Juliet was truly lifeless. The Friar might be blamed for this being too dangerous with out telling it to Romeo earlier than he gave Juliet the potion.
Put up isn’t at all times the greatest method of telling any person one thing that’s pressing, as we discovered. Though Friar Laurence’s plan seemed good, it was poorly thought out, this led to Romeo poisoning himself with Juliet when he was by Juliet’s “lifeless” physique. I feel if Friar Laurence had refused to marry them like he ought to have, none of this may have occurred, and his badly thought out plans simply made the state of affairs worse. Subsequently, I’m placing most of the blame on him for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. The Apothecary was the individual that bought the poison to Romeo.
The one argument you would have that it was the Apothecary’s fault is that he shouldn’t have bought Romeo the poison to kill himself . It takes a bit of persuading from Romeo and let him promote it, however actually all these persons are keen on is earning profits, and that’s precisely what he did. Romeo finally killed himself with that potion he purchased from the Apothecary, however he couldn’t be blamed as he didn’t know what it was for, the society standing of Romeo. He can’t be blamed. Many individuals who’ve seen or learn this play won’t blame anybody in any respect, however blame the deaths of Romeo and Juliet on destiny.
Destiny comes into play not less than as soon as in the play and has an impact on the complete end result of the play. When Friar Laurence is attempting to ship the letter to Romeo explaining of his plan for him and Juliet to run away safely, the letter doesn’t attain him as there’s a plague in the metropolis. Romeo due to this fact thinks that Juliet is definitely lifeless as he’s instructed by his kinsmen Balthasar. The letter would comprise the info to inform Romeo that Juliet isn’t actually lifeless and it’s all half of the Friar’s crafty plan.
That is the foremost time when destiny comes into play which impacts enormously the eventual deaths, as this went on to Romeo committing suicide. I feel that the opening Prologue means that destiny can have a big function in the play as, in accordance to the Refrain, Romeo and Juliet are “star-crossed” (as if stars management their destinies) and their love is “mark’d” by “demise. ” The Refrain additionally means that Romeo and Juliet have been destined for tragedy the second they sprang from their dad and mom’ “deadly loins”, in different phrases, they have been doomed from beginning.
We’re led to consider that Romeo and Juliet don’t have an opportunity of surviving. All in all, I feel that Friar Laurence is most to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. He might have stopped it there and then, however selected not to. There are different folks to blame as nicely, like Lord Capulet for placing Juliet underneath pointless strain and most likely making her very careworn, or it might all boil down to Mercutio taking Romeo to the Capulet ball in the first place. However total I feel Friar Laurence is most to blame.
You may additionally be keen on the following: romeo and juliet who is to blame essay, romeo and juliet essay who is to blame, how is friar laurence to blame for the death, who is to blame for romeo and juliet’s death essay, who is to blame for romeo and juliet’s death essay free