Usually in literature, writers unintentionally create works that tie very nicely with each other. Two works that join nicely are The Odyssey by Homer, translated by Robert Fizgerald, and “My Father on His Defend,” by Walt McDonald. Whereas McDonald’s poem underscores the tone of mourning and sorrow by the principle character, Homer’s work elucidates the tone of animosity and damage.
As beforehand said, the tone of McDonald’s poem, “My Father on His Defend” is one in every of mourning and grief.
The speaker of the poem is grieving his father who he misplaced to battle and experiences struggles in dealing with all of it. McDonald’s particulars concerning the sled talked about in the poem replicate the closeness that was as soon as there between the speaker and his father, in addition to the extent of significance the speaker’s father had in his life. The use of diction by McDonald additionally emphasizes the speaker’s mourning, usually accompanied by nostalgia, by implicating the repetition of the phrases “I keep in mind” all through the poem.
This fixed remembrance expresses the speaker’s problem coming to phrases together with his father’s loss of life. In distinction with McDonald’s poem, Homer’s work, The Odyssey, displays a tone crammed extra with animosity and heartache reasonably than the earlier, extra somber and mournful really feel. The most important character, up to now, is called Telemakhos. The character’s father has been gone for a few years with out returning or sending any messages, inflicting the boy and his mom to wonder if he has died, or if he’s gone as a result of he doesn’t want to return. By way of element, readers are capable of finding out that because of his father’s prolonged absence, quite a few suitors have begun to take free reign over their dwelling and all of their property, searching for to marry the attainable widow. Homer makes use of diction in order to point the Telemoakhos’ animosity in direction of his father:
Pal, let me put it in the plainest manner. My mom says I’m his son; I do know notsurely.Who has identified his personal engendering? I want a minimum of I had some completely satisfied man as afather,rising previous in his personal home – unknown loss of life and silence are the destiny of him that, sinceyou ask, they name my father. (Homer eight) Telemakhos is saying that though his mom and everybody say Odysseus is his father, he doesn’t really feel that manner as a result of he lacks any reminiscence of him. He needs he might have his father in his life, and is concerned by the very fact he hasn’t the slightest bit of information in regards to the whereabouts of his father.
Telemakhos and the speaker in the poem by McDonald share related experiences. They each are coping with the absence of their fathers who each partook in the army. Nonetheless, the speaker in the poem really is aware of for a truth his father has died, which can be why he copes with the dearth of a father higher than Telemakhos, solely as a result of he doesn’t must Question Assignment whether or not or not his father isn’t in his life as a consequence of sheer carelessness. As a result of Telemakhos hasn’t the faintest thought of his father’s whereabouts, he’s in seek for closure, not just for himself, however for his mom and property being destroyed by the savage suitors. Their circumstances are what management the tone in their dialog, permitting the reader to really feel the identical issues the audio system are feeling.