Single Peer-Reviewed Research Article Critique

Single Peer-Reviewed Research Article Critique Related to Superior Nursing Apply

  This analysis was carried out by three researchers who’ve expertise in conducting analysis research based mostly on their stage of qualification. Rona Parker is a registered nurse RN with a Masters Diploma in Schooling and a PhD who presently work as an Helpant Dean and Affiliate Professor on the Faculty of Osteopathic Drugs, College of the Incarnate Phrase, Texas. Her colleague Mary Jane Jones is a RN with a PhD and a Professor on the BG Lillian Dunlap Professor Emerita of Nursing on the identical College in Texas. The three^rd researcher is Linda Hook who has a Masters in Nursing, Superior Public Well being Nurse (APHN-BC), and MSHP. She works as an teacher on the IIa Faye Miller Faculty of Nursing and Well being Professions.

 The title of the article didn’t explicitly state the research inhabitants however inferences might be made that it entails sufferers with diabetes due to the inclusion of the phrase glycemic management. The opposite said variable is the Nurse Practitioner (NP) and the interprofessional collaborative apply crew which demonstrated a correlational research. The summary indentified the important thing parts of the research that included the background and function of the research, the design together with the pattern, conclusion and the implications for nursing apply.

Steps within the Research Course of

Drawback – the issue surrounds glycemic management of sufferers with diabetes and the power of the NP and interprofessional crew to enhance scientific outcomes. Glycemic management has been a problem for a lot of sufferers dwelling with diabetes and contributes to a number of micovascular and macrovascular problems which probably will increase the chance of untimely demise from these problems. Based on Parker et al, (2016), inorder for sufferers to totally profit from the well being care providers and be extra profitable at controlling their blood sugar their care ought to be addressed from the purpose of preliminary care with the supplier and with involvement from the interprofessional crew. With this mannequin of care facilitated by the NP, every member of the crew can maximize their interventions to enhance affected person consequence.

Goal– The issue was to determine variations of blood sugar management of sufferers in danger when handled by a NP and an interprofessional collaborative apply crew inclusive of the NP inside a one 12 months interval. (Parker, 2016).

Assessment of Literature- The authors reviewed a complete of 24 articles, of which 10 had been underneath 5 years, 9 underneath 10 years and four over 10 years, which demonstrated that these references had been present in relation to the time of research. Parker et al, (2016) reviewed earlier research on the improved results that nurse /supervisor skilled in diabetes administration had on diabetes management inside a short while span, however not a lot proof on total consequence. Additionally they checked out three research that talked about the involvement of self-management. One other that handled enchancment in glycemic management with extra frequent contact from well being care suppliers, and one other that appeared on the results of involving a case supervisor to self- administration training program. Parker et al, (2016) believes that the results of some earlier research could have been affected negatively based mostly on the confusion of the which means of illness administration, care coordination and what’s concerned in collaborative intervention. It’s important when a research to know the contextual which means of sure terminologies therefore the explanation for inclusions of a few of these phrases with their definition within the research.

Research Framework

Research Question Assignment- The authors states two analysis questions which had been:- 1) “What are the variations in glycemic management amongst sufferers with at-risk diabetes cared for by a nurse practitioner solely and people who acquired extra follow-along care by an interprofessional crew ?”(Parker et al, 2016). 2) Are there variations in pre-post glycemic management amongst sufferers with at-risk diabetes who’re adopted by an Interprofessional Schooling and Collaborative Apply (IPECP) College Group for 2 or extra visits by two of extra disciplines?”(Parker et al, 2016).

Variables: In danger sufferers with diabetes who had HgbA1C between 7-9% (average) and excessive threat > 9%.

Design: Sometimes the pretest-posttest analysis design would come with an intervention group and a management group for each pretest and publish take a look at. (Sutherland, 2017, Quantitative Methodology: Interventional Designs and Strategies). However on this research the authors determined to make use of the pre-post design with out the management group the place they checked out the results of glycemic management in at-risk sufferers with diabetes who was both handled by the NP solely and people handled by the interprofessional crew at a clinic inside the neighborhood. (Parker, et al, 2016). Right here beneath is a diagrammatic illustration of the analysis design-pre-post take a look at and not using a management group.