Posted: February 17th, 2022

Explain how you think a Kantian and a utilitarian would respond to the case of Baby Theresa

Question Assignment Description
I’m learning for my Philosophy class and want a proof.

(N.B. Please learn directions completely earlier than starting to reply questions.) Please choose three (three) of the following essay questions, and respond to them in the type of a transient essay of roughly 500-600 phrases. Be sure in every that you usually are not simply stating your positions on the questions, however giving the causes or arguments that you think help these positions, too. You can be graded not on whether or not you get the questions “proper,” however on the high quality of your arguments. Don’t do greater than three – further solutions is not going to yield further credit score. Select the three to which you can present the finest solutions, and write on these and these solely. A couple of issues to observe: • This examination is totally open-note. You’re free to use any notes or course materials to support you in creating your solutions. • That is a take-home examination. To show it in, merely connect your solutions to an electronic mail message to me, simply as you have for previous writing assignments. • Be sure that you keep away from plagiarism – there isn’t any cause for you to use outdoors sources to reply any of these questions. You could make use of my lecture notes to Help you perceive the related concepts, however be certain to reformulate issues in your individual phrases, simply as you would if you had been sitting this examination in individual in a classroom. • It is best to be happy to attain out to me if you have any clarification questions. I’ll attempt to Help you perceive what the questions are asking as a lot as doable, however I’ll (naturally) not give you direct Help in answering them. (Take a look at the subsequent web page to see the examination questions.) Listed below are the doable questions:

(1) Explain how you think a Kantian and a utilitarian would respond to the case of Baby Theresa, mentioned in Rachels’ “What’s Morality,” pp. 1-5? (See Unit 1 for a PDF of this studying.) Explain not simply the place they would take, however the causes and arguments they would current for taking it. (2) What would John Stuart Mill think about Robert Nozick’s “Expertise Machine” thought experiment (from Unit 2)? Would Mill think that we should always plug in to it, or not? What would his arguments be? (three) Is Todd Might proper to think that Aristotle’s advantage ethics can also be a type of “altruism” in his sense? That’s, does Aristotle’s advantage ethics demand a variety of selfless ethical perfection of us, as Kantianism and utilitarianism do? (four) What would a Kantian say about Todd Might’s ethics of “decency”? On what key factors would the Kantian agree and disagree? (5) Think about Peter Singer responding to Todd Might’s claims about the ethics of charitable giving. On what key factors would he agree and disagree? (Take a look at Singer’s “Famine, Affluence, and Morality” in Unit four, and chapter three of Might’s A First rate Life.) (6) Is that this assertion true or false? Help your reply with arguments: “None of the three main theories is admittedly true or false. They’re simply alternative ways folks would possibly want to stay. The disagreements between them imply nothing greater than the disagreements between folks about which is their favourite ice cream taste, or pop tune

Order | Check Discount