Posted: February 15th, 2022

The Criminal Justice System And Race Criminology Essay

Study Bay Coursework Assignment Writing Help

Conceptions of race inside the felony justice system have at all times been a controversial concern. Certainly, there isn’t any denying that by way of jail inhabitants ethnic minorities are grossly overrepresented: regardless of making up solely 2% of the entire inhabitants of Britain, black folks nonetheless make up 15% of the inhabitants of prisons (Ashworth). If one assumes that these statistics symbolize overt racism inside the administration of the felony justice system then requires reform and chance of change might be excessive, nevertheless there was a bent to see these statistics as presenting the proof of an irreconcilable drawback, of deeper seated decay inside, not simply within the decrease echelons of the felony justice system, however society as an entire (Chelitotis and Liebling). If that is so then the reply as to whether the felony justice system may be made to function equitably in relation to race could require a strategy of deeper reforms.

It’s essential to assess first the question of whether or not racism exists inside the system and in that case, to what extent. Bowling argues that there exists an ‘both, or’ debate; whether or not the overrepresentation within the jail inhabitants is the results of a better fee of black folks committing offences, or, conversely, the results of an accumulation of bias all through the felony course of. Waters, in his early article Race and the Criminal Justice Course of, means that the controversy may be additional outlined as people who fall into the ‘authorized elements’ camp, who imagine that the rationale for variations custodial sentence selections are authorized elements akin to severity of offence and former felony file (which can in themselves be the results of broader structural and financial elements akin to unemployment and poverty) and that these variables fairly satisfactorily clarify the predominance of black folks in jail. One the opposite hand the ‘extra-legal’ elements camp argue that over and above the racial discrimination skilled in society as an entire, black folks obtain unfair and inferior remedy by advantage of the ethnicity by the hands of a predominantly white justice system.Oxbridge Essays www.oxbridgeessays.com

The analysis performed by Hood would appear to recommend that there are in existence some further authorized elements and due to this fact discrimination in sentencing. Hood discovered that after samples had been matched on variables predictive of custodial sentences (e.g. seriousness of offence, earlier convictions, employment, and different pre-sentence report findings) there was a 5% higher probability of being handed a custodial sentence when you have been black, and that this distinction (which additionally resulted in black defendants being sentenced for three months longer and Asians 9 months longer the place a not responsible plea was entered). Nonetheless Ashworth highlights the truth that Hood’s analysis doesn’t account for the truth that extra black folks enter responsible pleas, select to come back to the crown courtroom the place sentences given are sometimes harsher and should disproportionately turn into concerned in additional critical crime. Thus the examine isn’t conclusive that there doesn’t exist an entire host of different elements why ethnic minorities could come to be inside the system within the first place. Certainly, Von Hirsch and Roberts of their reflections on the Hood examine spotlight the issues inherent within the assumption of a ‘degree enjoying area’ of the variables chosen. For instance, with employment: there may be proof that black folks undergo from drawback within the labour market, so to take this into consideration when sentencing would quantity to an oblique type of discrimination. Thus there are clearly deeper roots of discrimination which cumulatively outcome within the discrepancies seen. Chelitotis and Liebling argue that variations in ranges and patterns of offending could outcome from a vicious crime circle of stereotyping black folks as extra crime susceptible. This results in over-policing ethnic minority neighbourhoods, thereby drawing extra ethnic minorities into the felony justice web, consequently extending their felony data and which means they’re extra more likely to be sentenced severely. They’re additionally due to this fact extra more likely to be re-targeted by the police, ensuing, once more, in more and more punitive sentencing when they’re reconvicted. Thus it might appear the issue isn’t merely within the overt type of discrimination, however exists all through the system, maybe even worsening the decrease the visibility degree turns into.

One solely wants to try the cease and search statistics to see this borne out, black folks being 6.5 occasions extra more likely to be stopped and Oxbridge Essays www.oxbridgeessays.com ), resulting in ‘s remark that ethnic minorities are “over policed and beneath protected”. Nonetheless, as soon as once more the image isn’t so clear lower; it may be argued that what the figures truly symbolize is variations in the kind of crime dedicated, with ethnic minorities being extra concerned in ‘road crime’ akin to drug offences and due to this fact extra more likely to be stopped and searched in suspicion of such comparatively seen exercise. That is additional exacerbated by social and demographic elements and by variations in work and leisure life which imply that not solely are minorities in higher numbers in areas and at occasions the place searches happen, however that extra searches happen within the city areas through which they stay, through which unemployment and social deprivation are excessive (. Nonetheless the vast discretion accorded to police in such circumstances implies that the prevalence of minority teams within the figures suggests some type of racism.

searched than white folks, and Asians twice as doubtless (House Workplace 2005),given that almost all ofthese preliminary stops don’t result in anyfurther motion(87%), it might seemto recommend that that is merely proof of discriminatoryracial profilingand stereotyping.While the premise of such actions is of s1 ofPACE (which allows police to cease and search with onlyreasonable suspicion)and s60 CJPOA (which allows searches with out suspicion the place seriousviolence is anticipated or to searchfor weapons), andtherefore essentiallylegal, its train may be seen as focused (Quinton), resulting in Reiner’s remark that ethnic minorities are “over policed and beneath protected”.Nonetheless,as soon as once more the image isn’t so clear lower;it may be argued that what the figures truly symbolize is variations in the kind of crime dedicated,withethnic minorities being extra concerned in ‘road crime’ akin to drug offencesand thereforemore more likely to be stopped and searched in suspicion of suchrelatively visibleactivity. That is additional exacerbated by social and demographicfactors and by variations in work and leisure life which imply thatnot solely are minorities in higher numbers in areas and at occasions the place searches happen, butthatmore searches happen within the city areas through which they stay, in whichunemploymentand social deprivation are excessive (Philips). Nonetheless the widediscretion accorded to police in such circumstances implies that the prevalenceofminority teams within the figures suggests some formof racism.

Certainly, the Macpherson Inquiry into the Stephen Lawrence affair was elucidatory on the existenceof institutional racism inside the police system,outlined byMacphersonas “the collective failure of an organisation to providean appropriateand professionalservice to folks due to their color,tradition or ethnic origin, it may be seen detected within the processes, attitudes andbehaviour which amountto unwitting prejudice, ignorance,thoughtlessnessand racist stereotypingwhich disadvantages ethnic minorities” and thereforewould accountfor the disproportionate illustration ofblacks within the systemand for the excessive degree of racist incidents detected (police recorded racistincidents have elevated dramatically from4,383 incidents in 1988 to 52,694 in2004-House Workplace). WhilstLeahighlights that Macpherson’s dialogue oninstitutional racismfails to find with sufficientprecision its roots inside thestructure of operational coverage and the connection between policeand minority

Oxbridge Essayswww.oxbridgeessays.comOxbridge Essays www.oxbridgeessays.com too asserts that institutional racism does exist, and that it stems not solely from the occupational tradition of the police and the actual types of contact they’ve with ethnic minorities, but additionally from the idea that they’re “harmful courses”. Stopping and looking due to this fact represents a type of generalised surveillance of those that they imagine to have little political capital. In these methods Lea argues that racism does come up from the traditional functioning of the police system, a sentiment that was echoed by a remark from the Director Basic of the Jail Service 2001 when he mentioned that “the jail is an institutionally racist establishment which displays an institutionally racist white society”().

communities,Leatoo asserts that institutional racismdoes exist,and that itstems notonly from the occupational tradition of the police and the particularforms of contact theyhave with ethnic minorities, but additionally fromthe perception thatthey are “harmful courses”.Stopping andsearching due to this fact represents aformof generalised surveillance of those that they imagine to have little politicalcapital. In these methods Lea argues that racism does arisefrom the normalfunctioning of the police system, a sentiment that was echoed by a commentfrom the Director Basic of the Jail Service 2001 when he mentioned that “theprison is an institutionally racist establishment which displays an institutionally racistwhite society”(Lea).

Thus it may be seen complicated interaction of socio-economic, demographic,institutional, structuraland culturalfactors, alongside direct and oblique racialdiscrimination (Philips) are responsiblefor the overrepresentation anddiscriminatory outcomes evident within the system.Edgar and Martinconcur,suggesting that within the context ofdiscussion on discriminatory remedy withinprisons, the experiences of ethnic minorities needs to be see within the context ofexpectations which could have arisen fromcontact with different felony justiceagencies. Additional,Wacquentnotes that jail confines teams endowed with destructive symbolic capital, and that their stigmatisation constitutes half oftherelationship between the confined and thosein authority. Simply because the jail,heargues, could mirror exterior macro-socialtrends, “so can also it result in theirexistence by stigmatising and curbing the life probabilities of ethnic minoritiesfurther”. Thus as soon as once more,discrimination may be seen to be adeep-seatedissue, and one which isn’t essentially adequately addressed by combatingthe administration of the legal guidelines.Waters, in his article, expresses the necessity todistinguish between ideas ofequality and fairness.Certainly, it may be seenthat equality between remedy of black and white offenders does notnecessarily equate tofairness or appropriateness, and we must always attempt forjustice somewhat than equality per se in recognition that society is notequal. That is acomparative train the place high quality meansthatsameness is notnecessarily fascinating,and justice could demand some differentiation on groundsof race in an effort to deal with all folks equitably(Pinder). For instance, in relation tothe employment level above, recognising the inequalities within the labour market

Oxbridge Essayswww.oxbridgeessays.comOxbridge Essays www.oxbridgeessays.com notes, the problem for the felony justice system is to find at what level negotiated differentiation turns into an imposed discrimination. We have to distinguish between notions of course of and final result; justice and equity in the way in which legal guidelines are administered doesn’t essentially make them truthful in and of themselves. Thus, there exists discrimination on a broad degree inside the felony justice system, which must be recognised and addressed on the decision-making degree. As advocates, it’s obligatory to handle each the administration of the system with regard to race, but additionally the insurance policies themselves, and what’s obligatory to make sure that remedy all through the system is truthful.

and due to this fact not unduly discriminating towards those that are unemployed throughout sentencing could Help to furtherfairness general. As Van Dykenotes, thechallenge for the felony justice system is to find at what level negotiateddifferentiation turns into an imposed discrimination.We have to distinguishbetween notionsofprocess and final result; justice and equity in the way in which legal guidelines are administered doesn’t essentially make themfair inandof themselves.Thus,there exists discrimination on a broad levelwithin the felony justicesystem,which must be recognised andaddressed on the decision-making degree. As Von Hirschadvocates, it’s obligatory to handle each theadministration of the system withregard to race,but additionally the policiesthemselves, and what’s obligatory to make sure that remedy all through thesystem is truthful.

The truth of the matter, nevertheless, is that ethnic minorities do notcare whatreasonsunderpinthe discrimination they’re struggling, whether or not or not it’s due tobroader socio-economic elements or whether or not it points immediately from the personthey are dealingwith (Waters). The result’s an absence of legitimacy of their eyes,attributed to the felony justice system as an entire, leading to blackdefendants being extra more likely to pleadnot responsible and to optfor the Crown courtroom(Von Hirsch),thus furtherincreasingtheir propensity to be sentencedseverely. The drawback turns into perpetual:if the justice system is seen asinequitable it would breed defianceamong those that really feel they don’t seem to be beingtreated pretty, leading to afurtherhike within the overrepresentation ofethnicminorities inside the system. If the system is to made to function equitably in relation to race it would require a tall order of reforms. While direct and institutional racism may be addressed by ethnic minority recruitment drives inside the police pressure,and racial consciousness trainingfor all felony justiceofficials, the broadersocial-economic points would require change in politicaland social coverage(Hood and Shute). Whatis clearis that race is a covertissue;a troublesome drawback to attemptto deal with as so few are keen toacknowledge its existenceoutright(Bosworth). Thus maybe most pertinentwould be to extend consciousness of the prevalenceofbroaderforms of indirectdiscrimination and social inequality and to aim to maintain these considerations in

Oxbridge Essayswww.oxbridgeessays.comOxbridge Essays www.oxbridgeessays.com

thoughts in order that selections in any respect phases can, a minimum of as a lot as is feasible, be made equitably.